Quick Answer: Is Mulan 2020 Similar To The Original?

Is the new Mulan like the original?

2020’s Mulan is a darker, more violent retelling of its centuries-old source material than the 1998 Disney classic.

Because of this, it’s the first ever live-action adaptation of a Disney property to earn a PG-13 rating..

Why is Mulan 2020 so bad?

Disney’s live-action “Mulan” is a film that is as painful to watch as it is to review. The short explanation: the film abuses human rights, regurgitates current nationalistic myths, grossly appropriates one of China’s most beloved characters, and fails both Eastern and Western viewers alike.

Why is Mulan 2020 so different?

Instead of a dragon, a cricket and a love interest, there’s a phoenix, a soldier named Cricket and a new connection. There are tweaks to the cast of supporting characters. For starters, Mulan no longer has a guardian dragon named Mushu (voiced by Eddie Murphy in the animated movie) or a cricket sidekick.

Why is there a witch in Mulan?

But the Witch exists to show Mulan and the audience that these two women are also limited by same inevitable constraint: their gender. Because they are women, neither one is respected by their peers or their enemies. The Witch represents the endpoint of Mulan’s journey.

Is Mulan a Chinese?

Mulan is based on an ancient Chinese folk story called the Ballad of Mulan (木兰辞 Mùlán Cí). The Chinese mùlán means ‘magnolia flower’. It is a short folk story comprised of 392 Chinese characters that was created in the Northern Wei Dynasty (386–534).

Is the movie Mulan historically accurate?

Disney’s Mulan: 5 Things In The Movie That Were Historically Accurate (& 5 That Were Not) One of the complaints about Disney’s animated Mulan is the fact that it is not entirely historically accurate. … One of the biggest complaints about Disney’s animated Mulan is the fact that it is not entirely historically accurate.

Is Mulan 2020 same as the cartoon?

1998’s. Mulan 2020 and the animated Mulan tell very different versions of the same story, based on the Chinese poem “The Ballad of Mulan.” While the live-action remake is more faithful to the source material, the animated Mulan ultimately tells a better story.

Why did Mulan kill herself?

In the “Sui Tang Romance” version of the story, first released in 1695, Mulan only has sisters and a baby son, so Mulan takes her father Hua Hu’s place in the army. … Mulan is ordered to become a concubine, so she kills herself.

Why is Shang not in the new Mulan?

Part of the reason director Niki Caro chose to change Shang was because of the unfortunate implications of Mulan getting together with her commanding officer.

Why is Mushu not in the new Mulan?

Mulan audiences and Disney fans were quick to spot that Mushu was removed from the 2020 live-action remake streaming on Disney+. … Mushu may have also been removed due to criticism of the 1998 animated film’s portrayal of the talking dragon, according to the film’s producer.

How old is Shang in Mulan?

He looks about 23 at the beginning (when he first came out becoming captain). I know some time progresses, and then more before the time they actually marry. Considering some women at this time would marry men 20 years older than them or more at times, he’s age appropriate for Mulan.

Why is there a phoenix in Mulan?

Mulan accidentally breaks a family statue of a phoenix. In the animated film, Mushu breaks a statue of a stone dragon, which serves as the family’s guardian. Mulan’s father says the phoenix is the emissary of their ancestors in the new movie.

Why did Mulan get bad reviews?

Reviewers blasted the movie for having flat characters and a bland story with details that don’t make sense. Many people also appeared unsatisfied with how the film handles certain Chinese cultural elements. (There are some minor spoilers ahead for the new Mulan.

Is Mulan a flop?

The Failure of Mulan Is More Bad News for Hollywood. … Not only does it seem that Mulan made modest sums in the United States (though Disney has yet to release official numbers), but the movie also had a disappointing theatrical rollout in China. Another grand experiment by Hollywood in the COVID-19 era, another flop.

Is Mulan 2020 the same as the original?

Disney’s Live-Action Mulan Is Closer To The Original Story Mulan 2020, with a primarily Asian cast and Chinese American lead in Yifei Liu, corrects that, linking its plot and characterization more to the source material. In the animated version, Mulan announces she seeks glory for her family, but also for herself.

How did they find out Mulan was a girl?

30. After Returning Home, She Revealed Her Identity. In the Disney movie, Mulan’s identity as a woman is discovered by accident after she was wounded. She was nearly killed by Shang Li, as the penalty for a woman impersonating a soldier is death.

Who does Mulan fall in love with?

Li ShangIn the years since the initial release of Disney’s animated classic, Mulan, her love interest, Li Shang, has gained a lot of popularity, partly because many see him as Disney’s first bisexual character.

Why did they rewrite Mulan?

The team behind the new movie explained the change was down to the #MeToo movement – they felt Mulan’s officer becoming her love interest felt a bit off given his position of power. The fan pushback was largely down to the view Li Shang is a bisexual icon as he falls for Mulan before she reveals her true identity.

Add a comment